Book Review

On Wednesdays We Wear Black – How To Hang A Witch by Adriana Mather {Book Review}

How To Hang A Witch by Adriana MatherTitle: How To Hang A Witch
Author: Adriana Mather
Publisher: Knopf Books
Release Date:  July 26th, 2016
Standalone/Series: Unclear
Genre: Young Adult – Fantasy – Paranormal

Goodreads link

My rating in stars: 3,5 stars
My rating in words: I liked it

What it’s about:

It’s the Salem Witch Trials meets Mean Girls in a debut novel from one of the descendants of Cotton Mather, where the trials of high school start to feel like a modern day witch hunt for a teen with all the wrong connections to Salem’s past.

Salem, Massachusetts is the site of the infamous witch trials and the new home of Samantha Mather. Recently transplanted from New York City, Sam and her stepmother are not exactly welcomed with open arms. Sam is the descendant of Cotton Mather, one of the men responsible for those trials and almost immediately, she becomes the enemy of a group of girls who call themselves The Descendants. And guess who their ancestors were?

If dealing with that weren’t enough, Sam also comes face to face with a real live (well technically dead) ghost. A handsome, angry ghost who wants Sam to stop touching his stuff. But soon Sam discovers she is at the center of a centuries old curse affecting anyone with ties to the trials. Sam must come to terms with the ghost and find a way to work with The Descendants to stop a deadly cycle that has been going on since the first accused witch was hanged. If any town should have learned its lesson, it’s Salem. But history may be about to repeat itself.

My thoughts:

“Group silence can be a death sentence. It was in Salem”

How To Hang A Witch was a solid debut and a fun, slightly creepy Halloween read. It reminded me of both The Craft and Mean Girls, which is high praise for me. Yes, it has a few issues still, but overall I enjoyed this one so much that I flew through it in 2 days. And I will be keeping an eye on Adriana Mather for new books, whether they are a continuation of this story or something completely new. But first, let’s discuss How To Hang A Witch!

What I loved:

  • The atmosphere. I absolutely LOVED the atmosphere in this book. The story takes place during autumn and it felt like the autumn mood just seeped through every page of the story. From the haunted house to the creepy forests, I felt like I could see it all play out in front of me.
  • The history. It’s obvious that Adriana did a lot of research on  the history of Salem. The plot was infused with a ton of stories on the Salem witches and on Cotton Mather. I’ve always been interested in that history and I learned so much here and I can’t wait to research even more.
  • The plot. The story is very plot-focused and while that does have some negative impact on the characters (more on that later) it did mean the story was quite a ride. It felt like non-stop action and I just could not stop reading. I NEEDED answers, I needed to know what would happen, I needed to know who was behind everything. I was suspecting EVERYBODY. I’d like to say that when it is finally revealed, that I knew all along, but honestly… I suspected everybody so it was both a surprise and blindingly obvious!
  • The message. Yes, this story is about Salem and witches and ghosts. But underneath that, there is the message that bullying is dangerous, but silence in the face of bullying is even more so. Kudos for that!
  • Elijah. OK, I admit it, I like ghosts. Especially handsome, nice ghosts who are able to get you a croissant from Paris in no time.

That said, the story did have a few issues that took the story down to 3,5 stars.

  • An annoying main character. Samantha made me feel old. I caught myself thinking “Young lady, watch the attitude and show some respect” pretty much every chapter. And I don’t like feeling old.
  • The love triangle. Does it count as a love triangle when one of them is actually already dead and a ghost? Either way, I did not like it. It didn’t need to be there. It wasn’t overpowering to the story, but I would have liked it better if the relationship with one of the boys was kept as platonic.
  • Weak characterization. Because the book was so plot-heavy and moved so super fast, the characters suffered. The boy-next-door was just a nice boy who lived next door. The mean-girl-descendants were just mean girls descended from witches. I couldn’t get any feel for any of the characters. They all felt a bit flat and stereotypical.
  • Confusing villain motivation. Maybe it’s just me, but when the big revelation finally came I was confused. It did not make all that much sense to me. And then the ending came so abruptly that I was just left in my confusion.

So overall, it was not a perfect read, but I still really enjoyed it. The ending left me wanting more. I’m keeping my fingers crossed for a sequel because I NEED answers. And ok, I need more Elijah. I’d recommend this to anyone interested in Salem history and looking for a fun, quick Halloween read.

Favorite quotes:

“The air’s crisp with the smell of autumn, and the first few leaves have started to change color. The streets have that family-friendly feel. Store windows already have pumpkins and witches’ hats in them.”

Have you read How To Hang A Witch? What did you think about it?


  1. I think the main character would make me feel old with her actions also.
    And the dreaded triangle ugh. I like the salem witch trials concept but… there are some really annoying parts in this book it seems.

    1. It’s a really double book – it has some really great things in it, but there are a few issues still as well. I still really enjoyed it overall, but I completely understand people who say it wasn’t their cup of tea…

  2. I keep reading mixed reviews for this book and it sounds like you experienced some of the same issues other readers did. I’m torn because some of it sounds so good but then that bit about the annoying main characters is just ugh. I’ll probably still read it but won’t be in as big of a hurry. Great, honest review though!

    1. I do also have some mixed feelings about this one. I highly enjoyed reading this and I flew through it, but it was only after finishing that my mind kind of caught up with some of the issues. I’d still recommend it though, but if the issues feel like something you’d have a hard time with then maybe it’s indeed not a must-read either 😉

Leave a Comment: